I met Erin in my new mom support group; her son was 12 days older than Julian. We spent hours together with our babies when they were two and three months old, walking with strollers, going out to lunch, and when we went back to work, we created a nanny share at my house. She would come pick Paxton up every afternoon, but if he was asleep when she arrived, we’d sit and talk till he woke up. So as much as I believe that what goes on in other people’s houses is a great and intriguing mystery, I think Erin and I had exchanged as much information about our habits as humanly possible without marrying each other.
I knew that at Erin’s house, they had a mechanical baby swing which featured a side-to-side rocking motion, and that her baby slept in it for a good part of the night. I also knew that she did sit-ups in the dark while she waited for him to fall back asleep. And, I knew that she asked her pediatrician if letting the baby sleep swaddled in the swing while it rocked full force all night long was okay.
“Whatever works,” said the pediatrician, a mother of three.
When my second child was born, she was incredibly fussy and slept poorly.
“Give me that swing!” I demanded of Erin.
And for the next few months, Scarlett spent her nights swinging full speed side-to-side, till 6 am. My husband and I got used to the sound of the swing rocking against the wood floor in our bedroom.
When Heather’s third baby was born, the overnight swing had been normalized in our extended mom social circle. Sawyer spent his share of time in an Ergo while Heather was awake and in an electric pendulum made by Fisher Price when she was asleep. Through knowing other moms she trusted who had gone this route, she felt it was permissible.
At a birthday party recently, I was chatting with two second-time moms — one of whom was a doctor — who were struggling with their newborn’s sleep and I told them about the overnight swing. I said, “You don’t need my permission to do this, but if you feel like that makes it okay, know that I used a swing all night long with Scarlett.”
“I’m going to try it,” they both said. “And I kind of did need your permission,” confessed the doctor.
I’ve seen the power of permission at play in many contexts. Parenting writer Meagan Francis has said she hates the playground, giving loads of women the okay to confess that they, too, don’t like standing outside getting sand in their shoes for hours on end.
How about this one: At a social gathering, no one wants to dive into the food first. When the first brave soul dips a carrot into Ranch, others will follow. Permission to eat granted.
Sometimes we doubt our own ideas or instincts until we see them reflected in others, validating our emotions. Heather and I started this blog because we found that taking care of a baby was lonely as a one-on-one activity. The hours were long and it felt like we were always waiting for our little companions to either fall asleep or wake up. By putting this idea out there (here?) where others could see it, I hope that we’ve helped normalize that feeling.
It’s okay to feel bored, anxious, or to be counting the minutes til your partner gets home. It’s okay to look for distractions, to do things to entertain yourself, to explore activities not found in What to Expect In Your Baby’s First Year.
The advent of social networks is a huge shift for moms. Unlike when my mom had me, and had only one parenting book to look to for the answers, you guys can find permission anytime of day or night. But remember, you don’t even need to ask.
(illustration by Amy Saidens from The Rookie Moms Handbook: 250 activities to do with (and without!) your baby)














I love this! Can we all start giving each other permission for all kinds of parenting things? Whether its needed or not, it makes the tough parenting decisions feel much better.
My son (who’s now almost 16 months) slept in the swing all night long and for all naps until he was 5 months old. I was desperate…and he loved it. He often slept 3-5 hours at a stretch as an 8-week-old (and slept 8 hours once at 7 weeks). Transitioning to the crib was a little rough, and I’ve since worried about SIDS in the swing, but I completely agree with the “whatever works” philosophy! We need to stop judging one another and beating ourselves up with guilt and incrimination for every parenting decision.
Thanks for a GREAT post. I’ve been reading this blog for a few months now and I just love it.
Thank you! This post is especially pertinent to me at the moment. I’ve been feeling guilty for letting my now almost 3 month old sleep in a side to side swing most of the night. For the life of me, I haven’t been able to get him to sleep any where but there or between my husband and I in bed. In bed with us, he wakes about every 3 hours. In the swing, he sleeps a glorious 6-8 hours. So thank you very much for easing my guilt!
Thanks, Amy! Glad to have you as a new reader!
@Tinabot, whatever makes him sleep 6-8 hours, keep doing that!
My wedding photographer…sort of friend then…and I had babies two days apart. From the moment we found out we were pregnant, we became best friends. We daily asked permission to eat certain things, do activities, or asked ‘what did your OB say?’
I am so lucky to have her permission for all sorts of things. We have shared gadgets, walked many miles with the strollers, cried and laughed about it all over wine and ice cream. I love her dearly. And her son
@Kelli, that made me feel a little teary! I’m glad you have a partner-in-crime. It’s invaluable.
Amen! My group of friends who I met when Brooklyn was 2 months old has been invaluable in this regard — four years later we are all such good friends and permission-giving is a huge part of our friendships. Because while I try not to do the mommy guilt thing, it is hard not to sometimes and it makes a world of difference for someone you respect to say “Dude! You’re doing awesome and your kid is great…so who cares if you don’t want to go hang out at the park unless you have a friend there!” (Because yes that’s absolutely one of mine.)
Thank goodness for supportive friends who tell each other “Whatever works!” We have people in the group who sleep train and people who don’t; people who cloth diaper and people who don’t; people who do extended breast feeding and people who wean at a few months; and on and on and on. And the motto is “Whatever works and keeps your family happy” and that is a freeing thing to be reminded of:)
When my 5-year-old was a baby, I felt like such a failure that I often leaned on the swing to get her to nap ( she was a terrible napper! ) If only I had this kind of support at the time!
We used the swing too. We even used a bouncer and I can remember swaddling my son and bouncing him with my foot for ages to get him to fall asleep. I often thought that I was bouncing too vigorously for his little brain but he seemed to fall asleep just fine and loved it. Today he is developing normally, so brains intact!
Good articles on not asking for permission and making your own choices > http://www.poppywassle.com.au/controversial-corner.html
Will definitely be following you two ladies
I’m passing on this post to every new mom I know. So many things that I have done are things in direct contradiction to the manuals (and my mother-in-law) and come sometimes from collective wisdom of mommy friends. It’s extremely important to have that, especially in the first couple of months when everyone Has An Opinion and not all of them are constructive, and when you find yourself on Babycenter at 3am after 24 hours of no sleep and feeling judged just by the headlines.