It seems that everywhere I turn, people are talking about the pursuit of happiness. Just yesterday, my husband received a postcard in the mail from his employer, a huge communications company. The postcard displayed a bar graph of his compensation with color coded segments for money, health benefits, and the pursuit of happiness (which was a reference to the free services we get in our home from the company).
Last month, I learned that two girls makes parents happier than a boy and a girl. From British website Bounty.com:
‘BEST’ TO ‘WORST’ COMBINATIONS OF CHILDREN:
1. Two girls
2. One boy and one girl
3. Two boys
4. Three girls
5. Three boys
6. Four boys
7. Two girls and one boy
8. Two boys and one girl
9. Three boys and one girl
10. Three girls and one boy
11. Two boys and two girls
12. Four girls
Hmmm. So according to this list, more children equals less happiness.
Which reminds me that a year ago, I did read that the childless are more happy than parents. (I expect that the infertile are exceptions to this, so let’s clarify that it’s those who are child-free by choice.)
Did you know that there is a Journal of Happiness Studies? And of course you know about Gretchen Rubin’s bestselling book, The Happiness Project in which she spends a year test driving every theory and tip about Happiness to see which ones work.
I recently listened to a story on NPR about countries that are studying their people’s happiness, or social well-being, so that they can measure the success of the administration.
Now I’m having a hard time getting my arms around the concept of happiness. Can’t it change from moment to moment? Certainly for parents it does. When I go to pick my daughter up from school, I feel a happy rush of anticipation before I see her. When I spot her in the crowd of 3-year olds, my heart fills with pride. Then as she turns to me and I squat down to greet her, it can go two ways: a big hug that keeps my happy mojo going or a grumpy face with a pronouncement of “I don’t like you. I wanted Daddy to pick me up.”
The latter puts us on a path toward a twenty minute struggle to get out of the school, perhaps a screaming tantrum on the way to her brother’s school, during which I might be feeling tense, resentful, or frustrated. As we park and get out of the car, she might say, “Mommy, in Fairytale Land, there are pink toilets,” demonstrating to me that she has completely moved on with her day, leaving me to wonder if I am happy or not.
I have a vision of happiness that is the impulse to skip, to laugh a lot, to feel energized by everything. Is that what we’re talking about here?
Or are we talking about what I have: a loving husband, health insurance, two smart and reasonably behaved children, supportive parents, and enough money to house and feed us.
My current thought is that it’s only someone who is already pretty happy who has the time and mental space to start wondering if they are really, truly, happy.
Later this week, I’m going to share some thoughts out of Meagan Francis‘s book, The Happiest Mom. Before then, I’m wondering what you think about all this happy talk.















Maybe to some it’s just semantics, but I’m more interested in the pursuit of joy than happiness. I agree, happiness is fleeting and changes from moment to moment. Joy is a state of being and in my opinion reflects one’s view on the world and how we approach each moment. Does my cranky child make me happy? Not particularly, but does having her in my life give me joy? Yes absolutely and no bad day will change that.
Well put, Kirsten!
I am just a few chapters away from finishing The Happiness Project so I’ve been thinking about happiness a lot the past couple weeks. One of the points the author makes over and over again in the book that has really struck a chord with me is that happiness is usually relative. People determine their happiness by comparing their current situation to their own past circumstance or other people’s circumstances. Now that I’m paying attention I see how often this is true for me. For example: I’m significantly happier now that I’m on the other side of a recent bout with pneumonia than I was in the weeks before having it because I feel SO much better. I do think it’s easier to indulge in happiness navel-gazing when your basic needs are being met, but because it’s so relative I think you can pursue happiness no matter what your circumstance is.
Ooooh, good question Whitney. I don’t know about happiness. I know I want it. But, do I have it? Would I recognize it if it slapped me in the face (and would happiness even do that to a person?)? Not sure.
ooh ooh, the other week on NPR, I heard about this new book by Bryan Caplan called Selfish Reasons to Have More Kids. He based his research on economic practices but his tips and conclusions seem firmly rooted in the happiness project (don’t sweat the small stuff, enjoy your kids more!). Likewise, Meagan Francis unwittingly encouraged me to have more children because SHE became more laid-back as she had more babies. Please let that be me.
Oh crap! I’ve got 2 girls. =OPTIMAL HAPPINESS!
With a 3rd child (sex unknown) on the way. =DOWNGRADE!
What’s a mom to do?
Just kidding around of course. I’m gonna pretend I never saw that list. : )
Chiming back in to add that I really enjoyed Gretchen Rubin’s book The Happiness Project. It made me a real believer in the idea that there’s nothing wrong with striving for happiness, and a disbeliever in the idea that the “pursuit” of happiness will by definition leave one less happy. (I see that idea bantered around a lot – I noticed it printed on a Lululemon bag someone was carrying on the train recently!) Only by being more cognizant of what does and doesn’t actually make YOU happy can you go about maximizing your happiness. And I also like her point that it’s not a selfish pursuit. Being a happy person brings up the happiness levels of those around you.
Joy vs. happiness (as discussed above) does seem like a bit of a semantics game to me, but if the word choice makes a difference to you, then go with it!
And I guess there is some element of personal definition to all this, because I don’t think of my overall happiness as skipping/laughing/being full of energy as much as just being content with my current situation, feeling like I am enjoying the life that I’ve been given rather than struggling to keep up with it.
My 3 year old daughter has been asking me lately if I am happy, and every time I say yes. Kirsten has succinctly been able to put it into words better than I can. Happiness is more than how you feel in the moment, and can affect how you handle the momentary lapses into anger/sadness/etc.
Hi from Argentina. I agree with Kirsten and Allie in that happiness is a lot more than how you feel; emotions have highs and lows than usually we can’t even control. But we can decide to be happy, to be grateful fo what we already have…. or we may prefer to feel sorry for ourselves, and be miserable.
By the way, I’m way down on the list of “worst” combinations of children, I have 3 girls and 1 boy!!!! And I can honestly say that I AM HAPPY!
I read a book a while back titled The Geography of Bliss…or something like that. The author went around the world studying the cultures and societies that consistently scored highest on happiness indices. But he sensed something was missing. Bumping into a single mom with a toddler on an emotional meltdown one day, he asked her “Are you happy?” She looked at him and said “You’re asking the wrong question.” Turns out we most want a life worth living.
…”Happiness is an outside job, contentedness is an inside job.”